Destabilization of the SHP2 and SHP1 protein tyrosine phosphatase domains by a non-conserved “backdoor” cysteine

Abstract

Protein tyrosine phosphatases (PTPs) are critical regulators of cellular signal transduction that catalyze the hydrolytic dephosphorylation of phosphotyrosine in substrate proteins. Among several conserved features in classical PTP domains are an active-site cysteine residue that is necessary for catalysis and a “backdoor” cysteine residue that can serve to protect the active-site cysteine from irreversible oxidation. Curiously, two biologically important phosphatases, Src homology domain-containing PTPs 2 and 1 (SHP2 and SHP1), each contain an additional backdoor cysteine residue at a position of the PTP domain that is occupied by proline in almost all other classical PTPs (position 333 in human SHP2 numbering). Here we show that the presence of cysteine 333 significantly destabilizes the fold of the PTP domains in the SHPs. We find that replacement of cysteine 333 with proline confers increased thermal stability on the SHP2 and SHP1 PTP domains, as measured by temperature-dependent activity assays and differential scanning fluorimetry. Conversely, we show that substantial destabilization of the PTP-domain fold is conferred by introduction of a non-natural cysteine residue in a non-SHP PTP that contains proline at the 333 position. It has previously been suggested that the extra backdoor cysteine of the SHP PTPs may work in tandem with the conserved backdoor cysteine to provide protection from irreversible oxidative enzyme inactivation. If so, our current results suggest that, during the course of mammalian evolution, the SHP proteins have developed extra protection from oxidation at the cost of the thermal instability that is conferred by the presence of their PTP domains’ second backdoor cysteine.