Designing effective protected area networks for multiple species

Abstract

Protected area networks seek to ensure the persistence of multiple species, but their area and extent are limited by available land and conservation resources. Prioritising sites based on their quality, quantity, size, or connectivity is often proposed; potentially using the occupancy and metapopulation dynamics of individual threatened species as surrogates for network effectiveness. However, the extent to which the dynamics of species with overlapping habitat requirements differ, and the implications of this for the optimal network designs for multiple species, are rarely tested. We parameterise metapopulation models for 5 papyrus-specialist birds occupying a network of papyrus swamp in Uganda, each of which possess subtly different ecological characteristics and habitat preferences. We estimate how each responds to different strategies based on prioritising patch size, number, quality and connectivity. The optimal approach differed depending on the metapopulation structure and characteristics of each species. The rank order of strategies also varied with the overall wetland area available and the desired persistence threshold. For individual species, prioritising habitat quality achieved the highest levels of persistence and population size for an equivalent amount of land area conserved. However, connected patches showed greatest overlap across species, thus the most effective strategy to conserve multiple species in the same network prioritised habitat connectivity. This emphasises the importance of individual species' characteristics using the same habitat networks in conservation planning, and demonstrates the utility of prioritising protected sites based on the spatial connectivity of habitat patches, when aiming to conserve multiple species with differing or uncertain habitat requirements.