Desaturation event scoring criteria affect the perceived severity of nocturnal hypoxic load

Abstract

Objectives/BackgroundInterest in using blood oxygen desaturations in the diagnostics of sleep apnea has risen in recent years. However, no standardized criteria for desaturation scoring exist which complicates the drawing of solid conclusions from literature. Patients/methodsWe investigated how different desaturation scoring criteria affect the severity of nocturnal hypoxic load and the prediction of impaired daytime vigilance in 845 patients. Desaturations were scored based on three features: 1) minimum oxygen saturation drop during the event (2–20%, 1% interval), 2) minimum duration of the event (2–20s, 1s interval), and 3) maximum plateau duration within the event (5–60s, 5s interval), resulting in 4332 different scoring criteria. The hypoxic load was described with oxygen desaturation index (ODI), desaturation severity (DesSev), and desaturation duration (DesDur) parameters. Association between hypoxic load and impaired vigilance was investigated with covariate-adjusted area under curve (AUC) analyses by dividing patients into normal (≤5 lapses) and impaired (≥36 lapses) vigilance groups based on psychomotor vigilance task performance. ResultsThe severity of hypoxic load varied greatly between different scoring criteria. For example, median ODI ranged between 0.4 and 12.9 events/h, DesSev 0.01–0.23 %-point, and DesDur 0.3–9.6 %-point when the minimum transient drop criterion of 3% was used and other two features were altered. Overall, the minimum transient drop criterion had the largest effect on parameter values. All models with differently determined parameters predicted impaired vigilance moderately (AUC = 0.722–0.734). ConclusionsDesaturation scoring criteria greatly affected the severity of hypoxic load. However, the difference in the prediction of impaired vigilance between different criteria was rather small.