Depth selection and life history strategies as mutually exclusive responses to risk of fish predation in Daphnia

Abstract

We tested if pelagic crustaceans of the genus Daphnia use different anti-predator defences in environmental conditions that do or do not offer deep refuge from planktivorous fish. We kept Daphnia catawba in two series of 9-m deep enclosures with and without caged cyprinid fish Phoxinus eos. In one series of enclosures, Daphnia could select its depth of residence and hide in deep dark water layers to avoid anticipated fish predation, while in another series of enclosures, a plankton net barrier fixed at 2-m depth forced them to stay in subsurface zone exposed to fish kairomones. We compared depth residence and migratory behaviour strategies with life history strategies (body size and size at first reproduction, diapause induction) in Daphnia exposed or not to fish kairomones with or without deep refuge. In deep enclosures with fish, Daphnia spent daytime hours in deep dark layers while at night, they resided closer to the water surface. Yet, no change in life history parameters of migrating individuals was observed compared to the fish-free conditions. In enclosures with fish, where the net barrier forced Daphnia to reside in subsurface zone, they produced smaller offspring, matured at smaller size and achieved lower maximum body length compared to the fish-free conditions. However, they did not produce diapausing eggs. Our experimental study supports the hypothesis that diel vertical migration behaviour with daytime residence in deep, dark water are the preferred antipredator strategy chosen by Daphnia facing anticipated fish predation over life history changes such as reduced size and low growth rate which are used when dark deep refuge is not present or accessible.