Density functional theory: coverage of dynamic and non-dynamic electron correlation effects

Abstract

The electron correlation effects covered by density functional theory (DFT) can be assessed qualitatively by comparing DFT densities ρ(r) with suitable reference densities obtained with wavefunction theory (WFT) methods that cover typical electron correlation effects. The analysis of difference densities ρ(DFT)-ρ(WFT) reveals that LDA and GGA exchange (X) functionals mimic non-dynamic correlation effects in an unspecified way. It is shown that these long range correlation effects are caused by the self-interaction error (SIE) of standard X functionals. Self-interaction corrected (SIC) DFT exchange gives, similar to exact exchange, for the bonding region a delocalized exchange hole, and does not cover any correlation effects. Hence, the exchange SIE is responsible for the fact that DFT densities often resemble MP4 or MP2 densities. The correlation functional changes X-only DFT densities in a manner observed when higher order coupling effects between lower order N-electron correlation effects are included. Hybrid functionals lead to changes in the density similar to those caused by SIC-DFT, which simply reflects the fact that hybrid functionals have been developed to cover part of the SIE and its long range correlation effects in a balanced manner. In the case of spin-unrestricted DFT (UDFT), non-dynamic electron correlation effects enter the calculation both via the X functional and via the wavefunction, which may cause a double-counting of correlation effects. The use of UDFT in the form of permuted orbital and broken-symmetry DFT (PO-UDFT, BS-UDFT) can lead to reasonable descriptions of multireference systems provided certain conditions are fulfilled. More reliable, however, is a combination of DFT and WFT methods, which makes the routine description of multireference systems possible. The development of such methods implies a separation of dynamic and non-dynamic correlation effects. Strategies for accomplishing this goal are discussed in general and tested in practice for CAS (complete active space)-DFT.