Degenerative changes in the elbow joint after radial head excision for fracture: quantitative 3-dimensional analysis of bone density, stress distribution, and bone morphology

Abstract

Some investigators speculate that excision may lead to elbow arthritis and associated problems; however, evidence supporting this theory is limited. It is hypothesized that radial head excision causes bone density changes as a result of asymmetrical stress distributions, consequently leading to osteophyte formation. In this study, we sought to quantitatively compare the 3-dimensional (3D) bone density and stress distributions between operative and nonoperative elbows in patients who underwent radial head excision. Furthermore, we aimed to quantify the bone morphologic changes using 3D models in the same cohort. After retrospective identification, this study enrolled 6 patients who had undergone radial head excision for radial head fractures. We created 3D bone models using computed tomography data obtained from the injured and uninjured elbows. Humerus and ulna models were divided into anatomic regions, and the bone density of each region was assessed and described by its percentage of high-density volume (%HDV). We also constructed finite element models and measured the stress values in each region. Furthermore, we compared the bone morphology by superimposing the operative elbow onto the mirror image of the nonoperative elbow. The mean interval from radial head excision to examination was 8.4 ± 3.3 years. The %HDV on the operative side was higher than that of the nonoperative side at the anterolateral trochlea (77.5% ± 6.5% vs. 64.6% ± 4.0%, P = .028) and posterolateral trochlea (70.7% ± 7.8% vs. 63.1% ± 3.8%, P = .034) regions of the distal humerus. Reciprocal changes were observed in the proximal ulna, as %HDV was higher in the lateral coronoid (52.6% ± 9.6% vs. 34.2% ± 6.6%, P = .007). The stress distributions paralleled the bone density measurements. The operative elbows demonstrated an enlarged capitellum and a widened and deepened trochlea with osteophyte formation compared with the nonoperative side. In elbows treated with radial head excision, we identified asymmetrical bone density and stress alterations on the lateral side of the ulnohumeral joint and bone morphologic changes across the joint. These data support the theory that radial head excision contributes to ulnohumeral arthritis over the long term.