Defrost cycle performance for an air-source heat pump with a scroll and a reciprocating compressor

Abstract

A 10.6 kW nominal cooling capacity air-source heat pump was tested according to ANSI/ASHRAE Standard 116-1983 for the frost acumulation and defrost cycle. These tests required indoor conditions of 21.1°C (70°F) dry-bulb, 15°C (60°F) maximum wet-bulb, with outdoor conditions of 1.7°C (35°F) dry-bulb, 0.5°C (30°F) wet-bulb. The unit was tested with the original scroll compressor and a reciprocating compressor that yielded similar heating performance. Heating capacity for the scroll system peaked at 8.4 kW (2.38 tons), while the reciprocating system heating capacity peaked at 8.5 kW (2.42 tons) during the frosting period. Heating capacities for the two system configurations differed by less than 1% during the frosting period. Power demand for the scroll system peaked at 2.9 kW, and the reciprocating system power demand peaked at 3.1 kW. During the frosting period, the reciprocating system power demand averaged 7% higher than the scroll system power demand. The reciprocating system completed a defrost 5% faster than the scroll system. Scroll system defrost time was 6.8 min while reciprocating system defrost time was 6.5 min. The volume of condensate produced differed by less than 3% with 1680 ml (102.5 in 3) and 1640 ml (100 in 3) produced by the scroll and reciprocating systems, respectively. Discharge pressures during defrost were within 3% with peak values of 1315 kPa (191 psia) and 1351 kPa (196 psia) for the scroll and reciprocating systems respectively. The reciprocating compressor produced higher levels of discharge superheat, peaking at 53°C (95°F) compared to the scroll system peak discharge superheat of 47°C (85°F). Overall, discharge superheat for the reciprocating system averaged 18% higher than the scroll system. The reciprocating system produced defrost refrigerant flowrates that averaged 3% higher than the scroll system. Refrigerant flowrates for the scroll and reciprocating systems peaked at 3.7 kg min −1 (8.2 lbm min −1) and 4.0 kg min −1) (8.8 lbm min −1) respectively.