Defining cosmetic surgery

Nicola R Dean,Kristen Foley,Paul Ward

doi:10.34239/ajops.v1i1.29

Nicola R Dean, Kristen Foley + Show 1 more

Open Access

https://doi.org/10.34239/ajops.v1i1.29

Copy DOI

Abstract

An agreed definition for cosmetic surgery would be helpful for the purposes of discourse on ethics, patient safety, healthcare policy and health economics. One of the problems with previous attempts at developing a definition is the narrow frame of reference and lack of engagement with the full spectrum of academics and stakeholders. This review brings together the sociological as well as the surgical literature on the topic of cosmetic surgery and examines societal, ethical and healthcare aspects. It outlines principles of constructing a definition and presents a provisional definition for further debate, namely: Cosmetic surgery is defined, for the purposes of a healthcare payer, as any invasive procedure where the primary intention is to achieve what the patient perceives to be a more desirable appearance and where the procedure involves changes to bodily features that have a normal appearance on presentation to the doctor. In contrast, surgery performed with the goal of achieving a normal appearance, where bodily features have an abnormal appearance on presentation due to congenital defects, developmental abnormalities, trauma, infections, tumours or disease does not fall under the definition of cosmetic surgery. It is a given that “normal appearance” is a subjective notion. Determining whether patients have a normal or abnormal appearance on presentation will rely on the clinical assessment of the treating doctor.

Highlights

Cosmetic surgery is increasing around the world with a recent American Society of Plastic Surgeons Report suggesting an increase of cosmetic procedures of 132 per cent between the years 2000 and 20161 and a 2016 ISAPS survey showingDean, Foley, Ward: Defining cosmetic surgeryAJOPS | ORIGINAL ARTICLE a 9 per cent increase in procedures in a 12 month period.[2]
This review brings together the sociological as well as the surgical literature on the topic of cosmetic surgery and examines societal, ethical and healthcare aspects. It outlines principles of constructing a definition and presents a provisional definition for further debate, namely: Cosmetic surgery is defined, for the purposes of a healthcare payer, as any invasive procedure where the primary intention is to achieve what the patient perceives to be a more desirable appearance and where the procedure involves changes to bodily features that have a normal appearance on presentation to the doctor
Surgery performed with the goal of achieving a normal appearance, where bodily features have an abnormal appearance on presentation due to congenital defects, developmental abnormalities, trauma, infections, tumours or disease does not fall under the definition of cosmetic surgery

Summary

Introduction

Cosmetic surgery is increasing around the world with a recent American Society of Plastic Surgeons Report suggesting an increase of cosmetic procedures of 132 per cent between the years 2000 and 20161 and a 2016 ISAPS survey showingDean, Foley, Ward: Defining cosmetic surgeryAJOPS | ORIGINAL ARTICLE a 9 per cent increase in procedures in a 12 month period.[2]. It outlines principles of constructing a definition and presents a provisional definition for further debate, namely: Cosmetic surgery is defined, for the purposes of a healthcare payer, as any invasive procedure where the primary intention is to achieve what the patient perceives to be a more desirable appearance and where the procedure involves changes to bodily features that have a normal appearance on presentation to the doctor.

Results

Conclusion