Abstract

Section 1 of this paper provides an introduction to this new “algebra of conditionals”, addresses various plausibility tests for such an algebra, provides a Venn diagram disproving a supposed counter-example, and answers various other objections raised in the literature about the efficacy of this algebraic extension of logic and conditional probability. Section 2 greatly simplifies the calculation of the implications of a set of conditional propositions or conditional events. These results depend on defining a deductive relation for conditionals (actually two have been found) with the property that the conjunction of two conditionals implies each of its components. That seemingly innocuous property assures that the deductively closed set implied by a finite set of n conditionals with respect to the deductive relation is implied by the single conditional formed by conjoining all n of them. The results are illustrated by solving several examples of deduction with several uncertain conditionals.

Highlights

  • The general topic of conditional events and conditional probability continues to be an active area of research, [1, 2, 6]

  • The main purpose of this paper is to greatly simplify my previous expositions of deduction with partially true conditionals1. This simplification is due to the discovery of two new deductive relations on conditional events that greatly simplify the problem of computing the implications of a set of two or more possibly uncertain conditionals

  • It will be shown that including this additional conditioning of the premise conditional by the condition d of the conclusion conditional (c|d) in the definition of deduction for conditionals, makes all the difference when calculating the implications of a set of conditionals

Read more

Summary

Introduction

The general topic of conditional events and conditional probability continues to be an active area of research, [1, 2, 6]. The main purpose of this paper is to greatly simplify my previous expositions of deduction with partially true conditionals1 This simplification is due to the discovery of two new (at least to me) deductive relations on conditional events (and conditional propositions) that greatly simplify the problem of computing the implications of a set of two or more possibly uncertain conditionals. This problem arose when two Boolean conditionals (a given b) & (c given d) were “quasi-conjoined” and expressed as a single Boolean conditional (ab or cd) given (b or d), which (depending on the implication relation adopted) might not imply one or both of its components! This paper will eliminate that issue and answer some objections to the idea of treating conditionals whose components are Boolean propositions or probabilistic events as trivalent ordered pairs with operations that extend those of Boolean algebra

The necessity of conditionals
Definition of the conditional closure
Definition of equivalence3
Three-valuedness
Operating on conditionals
Reversion to the material conditional
Conditional conditionals
1.10. Indicative conditionals
1.12. Stalnaker Hypothesis defended
1.13. Modus ponens
1.14. Tautologies
1.15. Variable universes
1.16. More general conditionals
1.17. Random variables
1.18. The surprise execution day dilemma
Deduction
Deduction with conditionals
Optimal deductive relations for conditionals
Deductively closed sets of boolean propositions or events
Deductively closed sets of conditionals
Examples of deduction with sets of conditionals
Computer calculations
Findings
Summary & conclusions
Full Text
Paper version not known

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call

Disclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.