DEA environmental assessment in time horizon: Radial approach for Malmquist index measurement on petroleum companies

Abstract

The climate change and various pollutions have been influencing our societies and economies. The environmental assessment, to be discussed in this study, is increasingly important because it serves as an initial step toward pollution prevention. Corporate leaders, policy makers, researchers and individuals who are interested in environmental protection have been paying attention to the assessment so that they can prepare policy suggestions on the global warming and climate change. As a methodology for the assessment, this study proposes a use of Data Environment Analysis (DEA) in a time horizon. Most of data sets on the climate change are sampled in a time series where the performance of organizations fluctuates every moment. In applying the DEA environmental assessment to such a data set, it is necessary for us to classify outputs into desirable (e.g., oil production) and undesirable (e.g., CO2 emission) categories because all organizations usually produce not only desirable but also undesirable outputs as a result of their economic activities. To unify the two different types of outputs, this study incorporates the concept of natural and managerial disposability into the computational framework of DEA and extends them into a time horizon. For the research purpose, this study incorporates Malmquist index into the proposed DEA environmental assessment to examine an occurrence of a frontier shift among multiple periods. The frontier shift indicates a technology progress and/or managerial innovation during an observed period. The index is further separated into four subcomponents in a time horizon. These subcomponents are differently expressed under the natural and managerial disposability. Thus, eight different subcomponents on the Malmquist index are proposed to measure the frontier shift. As an application, this study uses the proposed DEA approach to examine whether the frontier shift (due to technology progress) occurs or not in the petroleum industry from 2005 to 2009. Our empirical study finds that the industry has not exhibited any major frontier shift under natural disposability, but showing a considerable frontier shift under managerial disposability. In other words, the petroleum firms have improved their environmental performance by eco-technology to reduce an amount of CO2 emission during the observed annual periods.