Damage assessment and the effectiveness of prevention: the response of ordinary unreinforced masonry buildings in Norcia during the Central Italy 2016–2017 seismic sequence

Abstract

Four regions of central Italy were struck by the seismic sequence of the 2016 earthquake in the country: Lazio, Abruzzo, Umbria and Marche. This highlighted the different behaviour of masonry constructions depending on the prevention actions carried out after previous earthquakes. In particular, although damaged, the masonry buildings in the historical centre of Norcia (Umbria region) behaved significantly better than those in other regions. Indeed, the strengthening interventions carried out after the earthquakes of 1971, 1979 and 1997 greatly affected the seismic behaviour of masonry aggregates (contiguous masonry structural units, MSUs) in the historical centre, which sustained limited damage and a low number of collapses. This paper discusses the empirical data on damage collected with respect to 670 MSUs by means of the first level survey form concerning post-earthquake damage, and usability assessments (AeDES). The forms completed for the survey relate to MSUs in the historical centre of Norcia and were produced by the technicians of the Umbria Seismic Risk Office. The analysis shows the correlation between the MSU characteristics of: age of construction and renovation work; type of vertical and horizontal structures; roof types and usability rating; and the damage level and extent thereof detected in vertical structures. The effectiveness of previous strengthening interventions and the analyses of the types of strengthening solution are also discussed. A case study aggregate is analyzed in detail in order to illustrate the importance of strengthening interventions on vertical bearing elements. The strengthening interventions resulted in a sound strategy to strongly reduce losses, even in a very vulnerable centre comprised of old residential masonry aggregates.