Cyclonic/anticyclonic gyre asymmetries: laboratory and intermediate-model experiments

Abstract

Abstract Laboratory models of rapidly rotating geophysical flows often show significant asymmetries with respect to the sign of the gyre forcing. In this paper we focus on the instability of separated boundary currents and the resulting transition to time-dependent motion in a slightly sliced cylinder driven by a differentially rotating lid. This transition occurs more readily for cyclonic (co-rotating) gyre forcing, when compared with that observed for anticyclonic forcing, even though the system Rossby number is very small. Quasi-geostrophic models are invariant to changes in the sign of the forcing, so a more accurate theoretical framework must be used to capture the observed asymmetries. An intermediate model, which includes a second-order nonlinear Ekman suction relation, is proposed and integrated numerically. The results are in significantly better agreement with the laboratory observations, and simple diagnostics illustrate which of the higher-order physical effects are responsible for the enhanced instability of cyclonically forced gyres.