CrystalM: A Multi-View Fusion Approach for Protein Crystallization Prediction.

Abstract

Improving the accuracy of predicting protein crystallization is very important for protein crystallization projects, which is a critical step for the determination of protein structure by X-ray crystallography. At present, many machine learning methods are used to predict protein crystallization. Here, we use a novel feature combination to construct a SVM model in the prediction of protein crystallization, called as CrystalM. In this work, we extract six features to represent protein sequences, namely Average Block-Position specific scoring matrix (AVBlock-PSSM), Average Block-Secondary Structure (AVBlock-SS), Global Encoding (GE), Pseudo-Position specific scoring matrix (PsePSSM), Protscale, and Discrete Wavelet Transform-Position specific scoring matrix (DWT-PSSM). Moreover, we employ two training datasets (TRAIN3587 and TRAIN1500) and their corresponding independent test datasets (TEST3585 and TEST500) to evaluate CrystalM by feeding multi-view features into Support Vector Machine (SVM) classifier. Two training datasets are employed for five-fold cross validation, and two test datasets are separately used to test the corresponding datasets. Finally, we compare CrystalM with other existing methods in the performance. For the datasets of TRAIN3587 and TEST3585, CrystalM achieves best Accuracy (ACC), best Specificity (SP), and the same Mathew's correlation coefficient (MCC) as the previous outperforming methods in the five-fold cross validation. In particular, ACC, SP, and MCC have surpassed the existing methods in independent test, which proves the effectiveness of CrystalM. Meanwhile, ACC, SP, and MCC are higher than existing methods in the five-fold cross validation for TRAIN1500. Although the performance of independent test for TEST500 is not the best, CrystalM also has a certain predictability in the prediction of protein crystallization. In addition, we find that only choosing the first four features can improve the performance of prediction for TRAIN1500 and TEST500, not only in independent tests but also in five-fold cross validation. This phenomenon indicates that the latter two features can not effectively represent proteins of TRAIN1500 and TEST500. CrystalM is a sequence-based protein crystallization prediction method. The good performance on the datasets proves the effectiveness of CrystalM and the better performance on large datasets further demonstrates the stability and superiority of CrystalM.