Crystal Resorption as a Driver for Mush Maturation: an Experimental Investigation

Abstract

Abstract The thermal state of a magma reservoir controls its physical and rheological properties: at storage temperatures close to the liquidus, magmas are dominated by melt and therefore mobile, while at lower temperatures, magmas are stored as a rheologically locked crystal network with interstitial melt (crystal mush). Throughout the lifetime of a magmatic system, temperature fluctuations drive transitions between mush-dominated and melt-dominated conditions. For example, magma underplating or magma recharge into a crystal mush supplies heat, leading to mush disaggregation and an increase in melt fraction via crystal resorption, before subsequent cooling reinstates a crystal mush via crystal accumulation and recrystallisation. Here, we examine the textural effects of such temperature-driven mush reprocessing cycles on the crystal cargo. We conducted high-P-T resorption experiments during which we nucleated, grew, resorbed, and recrystallised plagioclase crystals in a rhyolitic melt, imposing temperature fluctuations typical for plumbing systems in intermediate arc volcanoes (20–40 °C). The experiments reproduce common resorption textures and show that plagioclase dissolution irreversibly reduces 3D crystal aspect ratios, leading to more equant shapes. Comparison of our experimental results with morphologies of resorbed and unresorbed plagioclase crystals from Mount St. Helens (MSH) (USA) reveals a consistent trend in natural rocks: unresorbed plagioclase crystals (found in MSH dacite, basalt and quenched magmatic inclusions [QMIs]) have tabular shapes, while plagioclase crystals with one or more resorption horizons (found in MSH dacite, QMIs, and mush inclusions) show more equant shapes. Plagioclase crystals showing pervasive resorption (found in the dacite and mush inclusions) have even lower aspect ratios. We therefore suggest that crystal mush maturation results in progressively more equant crystal shapes: the shapes of plagioclase crystals in a magma reservoir will become less tabular every time they are remobilised and resorbed. This has implications for magma rheology and, ultimately, eruptibility, as crystal shape controls the maximum packing fraction and permeability of a crystal mush. We hypothesise that a mature mush with more equant crystals due to multiple resorption–recrystallisation events will be more readily remobilised than an immature mush comprising unresorbed, tabular crystals. This implies that volcanic behaviour and pre-eruptive magmatic timescales may vary systematically during thermal maturation of a crustal magmatic system, with large eruptions due to rapid wholesale remobilisation of mushy reservoirs being more likely in thermally mature systems.