Critical test of PM3-calculated proton transfer activation energies: a comparison with ab initio and AM1 calculations

Abstract

Intra- and intermolecular proton transfer activation energies are calculated by means of the semiempirical PM3 method and compared with ab initio results obtained at MP2/6–31G ∗ or MP2/6–31G ∗∗ level. It is shown that corrections for zero-point vibrational energy (ZPVE) and thermal contributions do not affect the correlation between semiempirical and ab initio results. The linear relationship obtained suggests that PM3, in spite of some weaknesses, can be employed with a certain confidence to predict proton transfer activation barriers of large molecules or to obtain semi-quantitative trends for large numbers of interrelated systems. It is also shown that PM3 and AM1 results are of comparable quality for intramolecular proton transfers, whereas PM3 is to be preferred for intermolecular reactions, in particular when water molecules are involved.