Critical Factors for Implementing Open Source Hardware in a Crisis: Lessons Learned from the COVID-19 Pandemic

Lucia Corsini,Valeria Dammicco,James Moultrie

doi:10.5334/joh.24

Abstract

The rapid spread of COVID-19 has created an urgent demand for critical items including clinical care equipment and protective personal equipment. The failure of traditional industry to meet this demand has led to a huge response from the maker community, who are rapidly mobilising to produce Open Source Hardware (OSH) solutions. Community-driven, distributed manufacturing is enabling production on a global scale never seen before. In this paper, we focus on sensemaking as a process by which meaning is given to collective experiences. We identify six case studies of OSH projects responding to the COVID-19 pandemic, and report on their activities between March-June 2020. In doing so, we uncover several novel collaborations that are emerging between the informal maker community and other formal institutions, including research institutions, non-government organisations and incumbent manufacturers. By observing and reflecting upon these experiences, we identify potential critical factors for implementing OSH in a crisis. We highlight the importance of establishing legitimacy and community management, as well as the enabling conditions in the ecosystem that make OSH more favourable. These findings have implications for various actors beyond the Maker community. In conclusion, we suggest several promising areas for further research. In particular, we believe that this initial study of OSH during the COVID-19 provides a foundation for further longitudinal studies of OSH in a crisis.

Highlights

The rapid spread of COVID-19 has led to a global shortfall in medical supplies (Chagas et al 2020)
At the project-level, critical factors include the development of project legitimacy and community management; at the ecosystem level, we uncover enabling conditions that are key to implementing Open Source Hardware (OSH) in a crisis
We document the contribution of OSH in a crisis, and we investigate critical factors that influence the development of OSH from idea to implementation

Summary

Introduction

The rapid spread of COVID-19 has led to a global shortfall in medical supplies (Chagas et al 2020). The failure of traditional industry to meet this demand has given rise to self-organising networks of makers that are mobilising rapidly via peer to peer networks (Corsini et al 2020) Across the world, these communities of makers are producing critical items to tackle the spread and treatment of COVID-19. Makers have a longstanding tradition of using digital fabrication tools (e.g. 3D printing, laser cutting and CNC milling) to locally replicate, adapt and customise digital design files that are shared via the internet using open source repositories such as GitHub (Corsini, Aranda-Jan, and Moultrie 2019; Corsini and Moultrie 2019). When oriented towards a common goal, these communities can constitute a distributed manufacturing network (Pearce 2020)

Objectives

Methods

Results

Discussion

Conclusion