Critical Evaluation of Biocontrol Ability of Bayoud Infected Date Palm Phyllospheric Bacillus spp. Suggests That In Vitro Selection Does Not Guarantee Success in Planta

Abstract

The vascular wilt of date palm (Phoenix dactylifera L.), also known as Bayoud and caused by Fusarium oxysporum f.sp. albedinis (FOA), is the most destructive disease in North Africa. The disease has resulted in huge economic losses due to declining crop yield and quality. The use of potential biocontrol agents is a sustainable and environmentally friendly strategy compared to synthetic fungicides. The use of date palm-associated microflora for the screening of native antagonistic bacteria with potential applications is the most promising way to control this disease. Thus, the epidemic palm groves (in the valley of M’zab-Ghardaia-Algeria) were chosen for the isolation of rhizospheric bacteria and endophytes from the soil and roots of healthy or infected plants. A total of 8 bacterial isolates (83, 84, 300, 333, 322, 260, 249, and 227) selected from 75 FOA-active strains, showed strong activity against several strains of FOA and other major plant pathogens. Their phylogenetic identification proved they belong to the genus Bacillus (Bacillus sp., B. subtilis, B. atrophaeus, B. halotolerans, B. amyloliquefasiens, and B. paralicheformis). Bacterial cultures and a cell-free culture supernatant tested alone or in co-culture showed FOA inhibitory activity. However, the effect of the co-culture did not show any synergy in both cases. Unlike diffusible compounds, volatile organic compounds did not show a significant antifungal ability. The concept of selecting biocontrol agents in vitro does not always guarantee in vivo performance. In addition to antibiosis, other strategies such as competition and resistance induction are required for biocontrol agent efficacy. To evaluate the biocontrol effect in vivo, germinated seeds of date palm were treated with bacteria, infected with the pathogen, and then incubated for 45 days at room temperature in the dark. The majority of the strains (84, 300, and 333) tested showed moderate fungistatic effects and the protection rate reached an average of 60%. In particular, promising results were obtained with B. paralicheniformis strain 260 which significantly protected palm seeds up to 85%, compared to its in vitro test where a low inhibition rate (27.77%) was recorded. Screening methods should be equipped with multifactorial or plant-mediated control mechanisms. Furthermore, these bacteria have shown other potentialities to improve plant growth and resist stressful conditions. Thus, an effective biocontrol agent must combine several beneficial characteristics to be used successfully in situ. In this respect, Bacillus remains the best candidate for biological control.