Criteria to detect macroscopic quantum coherence, macroscopic quantum entanglement, and an Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox for macroscopic superposition states

Abstract

According to classical theory, a system with two or more macroscopically distinct states available to it is in one of those states at all times. Quantum mechanics gives a different interpretation where the system can be in a superposition of such states. In this paper, we derive criteria in the form of inequalities to detect this effect, referred to as mesoscopic quantum coherence, where the states are (at least) mesoscopically distinct. Such criteria are also signatures of a mesoscopic Schr\odinger cat paradox. We extend the treatment to consider definitions and criteria for mesoscopically entangled states, which are a subset of the states exhibiting mesoscopic quantum coherence. It is shown how the criteria (referred to as type I criteria) can be applied to detect the mesoscopic entanglement of systems prepared in NOON states, Greenberger-Horne-Zeilinger states, and entangled cat states involving coherent states. Here, a larger system $C$ is entangled with a second system $S$, which can be small. The proposed definition of mesoscopic (macroscopic) entanglement involves the Schmidt decomposition, and can be applied to systems in a superposition of many states, only some pairs of which are mesoscopically (macroscopically) distinguishable. We prove that a higher-order Hillery-Zubairy entanglement criterion will detect mesoscopic entanglement of this type, and use this to demonstrate the mesoscopic entanglement of the ground state of a two-mode Bose-Einstein condensate. Finally, we explain how a subset of the type I criteria (called type II criteria) are EPR steering inequalities allowing realization of a mesoscopic or macroscopic version of the Einstein-Podolsky-Rosen paradox for macroscopic superposition states. Where the two systems $C$ and $S$ are spatially separated, we then use results from the literature to point out it is not possible to complete quantum mechanics using hidden-variable theories compatible with the assumption of locality between the two systems. The violation of certain Bell inequalities is sufficient to prove this result, which gives a stricter signature of the Schr\odinger cat paradox and of mesoscopic quantum coherence. We call such signatures type III criteria.