Criteria for surgical decision-making in talocalcaneal tarsal coalitions

Abstract

Assessment and management of talocalcaneal middle facet tarsal coalitions present a complex orthopedic challenge. Various studies have attempted to establish guidelines for surgical intervention based on coalition size and hindfoot alignment. Our paper reviews the historical focus on coalition size, suggesting instead that posterior facet health is a more appropriate consideration for surgical decision making. Additionally, we challenge the traditional method for evaluating hindfoot alignment and propose a more accurate evaluation method. This critical review intends to highlight flaws in historical literature, aiming to trigger a reevaluation of the criteria for surgical intervention in talocalcaneal tarsal coalitions and promote future research studies driven by data and scientifically validated methodologies. Level of evidenceV