Cranial morphology and development: new light on the evolution of language

Abstract

A hypothesis is presented which may explain within a single framework both the large behavioural differences and the large differences in head morphology between the great apes and humans. All these differences can be parsimoniously explained by a shift of few regulatory genes controlling the onset of the division of late migrating neurons in the human cortex. This simple shift resulted in the following effects: 1) the neurocranium responded to brain enlargement by increasing mineral deposition on its external surface, increasing its overall size and mass. 2) This increase in the braincase was largely achieved by developmental reabsoption of the face bones. 3) The relative shift in growth between these two skull components also induced a rearrangement at the basicranium level. This brought about the facial orthognatism of modernHomo and, as a mechanical by-product, the descent of the larynx into the throat. Brain enlargement led to a large increase in cognitive capacity, and as a developmental byproduct, produced a mechanical organ preadapted for speech, as well as bringing about the reduction of canines and the origin of the chin. In this study, the phylogenetic basis, the selective pressures, and the behavioural consequences of this process during hominization are examined. Cognitiveversus communicative aspects of human language are distinguished and discussed. Cognitive capacities were the first to be selected due to the survival advantage of mapping huge territories during the expansion of the Plio-Pleistocene savanna ecotone. The present hypothesis is then compared with current theories leading to the conclusion that it is a more parsimonious explanation. It integrates data from a wide array of fields of human biology, pathology and clinical medicine, all assessed from evolutionary and ecological perspectives.