Cost-benefit analysis of human adenovirus vaccine development in a Korean military setting

Abstract

BackgroundHuman adenovirus (HAdV) is a prevalent causative agent of acute respiratory disease (ARD) and is frequently responsible for outbreaks, particularly in military environments. Current vaccines do not effectively cover HAdV subtypes commonly found among Korean military personnel, highlighting the need for a new targeted vaccine. This study presents a cost-benefit analysis to evaluate the economic viability of developing and implementing such a vaccine within a military context. MethodsWe adopted a societal perspective for this cost-benefit analysis, which included estimating costs associated with vaccine development, production, and distribution over a projected timeline. We assumed a development period of five years, after which vaccine production and administration were initiated in the sixth year. The cost associated with vaccine development, production, and dispensation was considered. The benefits were calculated based on both direct and indirect cost savings from preventing HAdV infections through vaccination. All financial figures were expressed in 2023 US dollars. A sensitivity analysis was conducted to explore the impact of varying factors such as vaccination rate, incidence of infection, vaccine efficacy, and discount rate. ResultsFor the base case scenario, we assumed a vaccination rate of 100 %, an incidence rate of 0.02, and a vaccine efficacy of 95 %, applying a 3 % discount rate. Initially, in the sixth year, the benefit-cost ratio stood at 0.71, suggesting a cost disadvantage at the onset of vaccination. However, this ratio improved to 1.32 in the following years, indicating a cost benefit from the seventh year onward. The cumulative benefit-cost ratio over a decade reached 2.72. The outcomes from the sensitivity analysis were consistent with these findings. ConclusionOur cost-benefit analysis demonstrates that the introduction of an HAdV vaccine for the Korean military is economically advantageous, with substantial cost benefits accruing from the seventh year after the commencement of vaccination.