Correlations between quartz OSL dose-response curve and TL glow curve characteristics, and their implications for equivalent dose estimation

Abstract

Optically stimulated luminescence (OSL) dating of quartz using the single-aliquot regenerative-dose (SAR) procedure requires construction of dose-response curves (DRCs). The shapes of DRCs and their characteristic saturation doses (D0 values) are well-known to be highly variable between samples and among individual grains from the same sample, but the factors that control DRC characteristics are imperfectly understood. Here we report correlations between OSL DRC shapes and thermoluminescence (TL) glow curve characteristics for a sample of quartz from northern Australia. Individual grains were measured using the SAR procedure and one of two preheat temperatures (160 °C and 260 °C), and grouped according to similarities in their DRC shapes. Grains from each DRC group were then physically transferred onto a separate disc for TL measurement as a multi-grain aliquot. A strong correlation was observed between DRC group and laboratory-irradiated TL glow curve shapes, along with some differences between the two preheats. Irrespective of the selected preheat, earlier saturating DRC groups are associated with the most intense 110 °C TL signal, and the least intense 325 °C TL signal, which corresponds to the main OSL trap. Later saturating DRC groups generally show the opposite trend. There are also trends within other regions of the glow curve and DRC group, such as prominent TL responses at 140–160 °C, 220–240 °C and 390–410 °C. We assessed the effect on the accuracy of equivalent dose (De) estimation using an associated radiocarbon age as an independent cross-check of the OSL ages for the DRC groups. De over- and under-estimates were obtained for some DRC groups. Most notably, grains preheated to 160 °C displayed a pattern of De values which decreased with an increase in D0. We relate this to variable concentrations of charge at the ∼230 °C TL trap prior to regenerative dose OSL measurements. OSL ages for most DRC groups preheated to 260 °C are close to the radiocarbon age, as are those of later saturating DRC groups preheated to 160 °C; the latter DRC groups have the smallest TL signals at ∼230 °C relative to the TL peak at 325 °C. The results of this study suggest that correlations between single-grain De and D0 values can occur due to underlying differences in the TL characteristics of grains with different DRC shapes. In the absence of independent age control and prior to measuring multi-grain aliquots of quartz, we recommend that OSL dating practitioners screen their samples for any single-grain patterns of De as a function of DRC shape, to determine the optimal SAR measurement conditions and data-analysis procedures for De estimation.