Correlation between in vitro toxicity of pesticides and in vivo risk guidelines in support of complex operating site risk management: A meta-analysis.

Abstract

In vitro cell systems can support hazard characterization and identify mechanisms involved in toxicity; however, using in vitro data for risk assessment still is challenging. As part of an effort to develop approaches for a complex operating site used for biocide packaging and distribution, we evaluated in vitro assays that could be used in a site management format. Across 66 studies, 108 pesticides were assessed on ten human-derived cell types at four endpoints. In vitro IC50s were compared to in vivo guidelines, NOEL/NOAELs, and ADIs using Spearman correlation and linear regression models. While human neuroblastoma cells (SH-SY5Y) were the most sensitive, HepG2 was the most used cell line in evaluating the toxicity of pesticides. Amongst the ten human cell lines, the IC50s derived from SH-SY5Y cells, using MTT-24 & 48h (the most used assay) correlated (rho=0.56-0.79; p<0.05) with ADIs and NOEL/NOAELs. Although in vitro cell systems have some limitations, the correlation between in vitro data derived from SH-SY5Y cells and in vivo safety guidelines can provide site investigators with a tool to survey and prioritize areas and media of concern at complex operating sites impacted by pesticide mixtures.