Conversion of Natural Soil to Paddy Promotes Soil Organic Matter Degradation in Small-Particle Fractions: δ13C and Lipid Biomarker Evidence

Abstract

The stabilization mechanism of soil organic matter (SOM) has received considerable attention. It is widely accepted that mineral sorption/protection is important for SOM stabilization. However, it remains unclear which organic carbon component is beneficial for mineral protection. We collected soil samples from a paddy field (TP) to compare with natural soil (NS). To illustrate the behavior of different SOM pools and their protection by particles, we separated the soils into different particle-size fractions and then removed the active minerals using an acid mixture (1 M HCl/10% HF). The different carbon pools were analyzed using stable carbon isotopes and lipid biomarkers. Our study showed that acid treatment evidently increased the extractability of free lipids, usually over 60%, which confirmed the predominant role of minerals in SOM protection. For NS, the δ13C values increased with decreasing soil particle sizes and soil depths, indicating that 13C-enriched SOM was selectively preserved. However, this trend disappeared after cultivation, which was mainly attributed to the combined effects of the input of 13C-depleted fresh SOM and decomposition of the preserved 13C-enriched SOM. Meanwhile, based on the degradation parameters of the overall lipid biomarkers, SOM showed higher degradation states in clay and silt fractions than in the sand fraction before cultivation. It is possible that the small particle-size fractions could selectively absorb highly degraded SOM. The clay-associated SOM showed a low degradation state, but its carbon content was low after cultivation. We propose that the previously protected SOM was degraded after cultivation and was replaced by relatively fresh SOM, which should be carefully monitored during SOM management.