Convection induced by selective absorption of radiation: A laboratory model of conditional instability

Abstract

When there is internal heating in a fluid layer, convection can occur even if the static state is one of stable stratification. We have been investigating through laboratory experiments such a stably stratified layer of water which is heated above and cooled below. The water contains in dilute solution thymol blue (a pH indicator), which normally colors the water orange. It turns yellow if the pH is low, blue if the pH is high. A small DC voltage is applied across the layer, by using the bottom boundary as the positive electrode, the top boundary as the negative electrode. The hydroxyl ions formed near the bottom boundary cause the orange fluid to turn blue. The fluid layer is uniformly and steadily illuminated from above with light from a sodium vapor lamp. This radiation travels with negligible absorption through the orange fluid but is strongly absorbed by the blue fluid. The resultant warming of the blue fluid can lead to convective instability, with the blue fluid rising into warm upper layers, which it would continue to penetrate as long as it remains blue and as long as the radiative heating is sufficient to exceed the higher ambient temperatures above. This radiative heating occurs only in the blue rising flow; the sinking fluid is orange and is not heated. We have found that with a strongly stably stratified layer, convective plumes are unable to penetrate far and they remain shallow. However, for a weakly stratified layer, plumes grow tall and furthermore collect into a large convective cluster which persists as a steady coherent structure. The present paper deals also with the formulation of the governing equations to include the fluid-state-dependent heat source. A linear stability analysis shows that the critical Rayleigh number for onset of motion is drastically reduced. Furthermore, the cell size at onset is larger by a factor of √32 than in the classical Rayleigh-Benard convection problem. However, the laboratory fluid cells were much further broadened (by a factor of 8 or 10) when they penetrated into the stably stratified fluid above. In this case, the rising region is narrow and the sinking region is broad, so that downward vertical velocities are correspondingly small. In this way, the downwards-forced warm fluid has time to cool by conduction to the cold boundary. Steady finite amplitude solutions and their stability are analyzed and it is shown that there is a parameter range in which finite amplitude hexagonal cells are stable.