Control of Ostwald Ripening by Using Surfactants with High Surface Modulus

Abstract

We describe results from systematic measurements of the rate of bubble Ostwald ripening in foams with air volume fraction of 90%. Several surfactant systems, with high and low surface modulus, were used to clarify the effect of the surfactant adsorption layer on the gas permeability across the foam films. In one series of experiments, glycerol was added to the foaming solutions to clarify how changes in the composition of the aqueous phase affect the rate of bubble coarsening. The experimental results are interpreted by a new theoretical model, which allowed us to determine the overall gas permeability of the foam films in the systems studied, and to decompose the film permeability into contributions coming from the surfactant adsorption layers and from the aqueous core of the films. For verification of the theoretical model, the gas permeability determined from the experiments with bulk foams are compared with values, determined in an independent set of measurements with the diminishing bubble method (single bubble attached at large air-water interface) and reasonably good agreement between the results obtained by the two methods is found. The analysis of the experimental data showed that the rate of bubble Ostwald ripening in the studied foams depends on (1) type of used surfactant-surfactants with high surface modulus lead to much slower rate of Ostwald ripening, which is explained by the reduced gas permeability of the adsorption layers in these systems; (2) presence of glycerol which reduces the gas solubility and diffusivity in the aqueous core of the foam film (without affecting the permeability of the adsorption layers), thus also leading to slower Ostwald ripening. Direct measurements showed that the foam films in the studied systems had very similar thicknesses, thus ruling out the possible explanation that the observed differences in the Ostwald ripening are due to different film thicknesses. Experiments with the Langmuir trough were used to demonstrate that the possible differences in the surface tensions of the shrinking and expanding bubbles in a given foam are too small to strongly affect the rate of Ostwald ripening in the specific systems studied here, despite the fact that some of the surfactant solutions have rather high surface modulus. The main reason for the latter observation is that the rate of surface deformation of the coarsening bubbles is extremely low, on the order of 10(-4) s(-1), so that the relaxation of the surface tension (though also slow for the high surface modulus systems) is still able to reduce the surface tension variations down to several mN/m. Thus, we conclude that the main reason for the reduced rate of bubble Ostwald ripening in the systems with high surface modulus is the low solubility and diffusivity of the gas molecules in the respective condensed adsorption layers (which have solid rather than fluid molecular packing).