Control location could confuse the evaluation of passivation effect of iron-based biochar and selenium application on wheat grain cadmium accumulation

Abstract

Inhibiting cadmium (Cd) accumulation in wheat grain could reduce the risk of Cd exposure to human. This study conducted a field experiment and evaluated the effect of iron-based biochar and selenium (Se) application individually or together on Cd accumulation in wheat grains in Cd contaminated soils. Considering the soil Cd heterogeneity in field, we set up 13 replicates of control (CK) and three replicates of each treatment. Results clearly showed that CK location could greatly affect the evaluation whether the difference in the wheat grain Cd concentration between treatments and CK was significant. When we assessed the difference between the treatments (foliar and soil application of Se, iron-based biochar application) and the adjacent CK, there was insignificant difference in the wheat grain Cd concentration between treatment and CK groups. Although soil application of 2 mg kg-1 Se or foliar application of 4 mg L-1 Se significantly increased the grain Se concentration as compared with the adjacent CK, but they still could not reduce the Cd concentrations in wheat grain. However, when we selected the CK that had the highest averaged grain Cd concentration, foliar and soil application of Se could significantly reduce the wheat grain Cd concentration by 47.7% and 41.3-46.1%, respectively. No matter which CK was selected, application of Fe-based biochar had no significant impact on Cd accumulation in wheat grain, and there was insignificant difference in DTPA-Cd concentrations between the iron-based biochar treatment and adjacent control. In conclusion, applying Fe-based biochar and Se in the field could not reduce the Cd accumulation in wheat grain in Cd contaminated weakly alkaline soils.