Contrasting the geochemistry of aluminum among peatlands

Abstract

Aluminum concentrations were measured in surface waters, pore waters and surface peats of 15 wetlands in south-central Ontario. Wetlands were grouped floristically and chemically as mineralpoor, moderately-poor or mineral-rich fen. Mineral-poor fens were dominated bySphagnum, were low in alkalinity (0.31μeq L−1) and pH (4.5–6.3). Moderately-poor fens had a mixture of vegetation (Sphagnum, sedges and grasses), mid-alkalinity (23–91μeq L−1) and pH (5.8–6.4). Mineral-rich fens were dominated by sedges and grasses, had high alkalinity (104–181μeq L−1) and circumneutral pH (6.2–6.3). Surface water Al concentrations were less in mineral-poor versus moderately-poor and mineral-rich fens (F=32.0; P<0.05). Pore water Al concentrations were lower in 4 of 5 mineral versus the mineral-rich fens (F=92.15; P<0.05). In all but two cases pore water Al (all species <0.2μm) were greater within the fen peats versus the overlying surface waters suggesting that peats could act as a source of Al to the overlying waters. In all wetlands, 70 and 30% of peat Al was recovered by a hydroxylamine hydrochloride/acetic extract (primarily inroganic) and an ammonium hydroxide extract (primarily organic), respectively. Differences in “extractable” Al recovered by the two reagents (i.e., inorganic+organic Al) among the 15 wetlands were independent of wetland type. Distribution coefficients, k d , were different among the 3 types of wetlands (F=25.0; P<0.05) with theSphagnum dominated mineral-poor fens containing higher values versus the sedge and grass dominated mineral-rich fens. Lower surface and pore water concentrations of Al in mineralpoor versus mineral-rich fens may in part be a result of differences in the degree of minerotrophic influences between the two types of peatlands. As well, the greater binding capacity ofSphagnum peat as indicated by higher k d 's in the mineral-poor fens, may have contributed to the observed lower pore water and surface water Al concentrations in mineral-poor versus mineral-rich fens. It has been postulated that anthropogenic acidification of peatlands will accelerate the transformation of a mineral-rich fen to that of a mineral-poor fen and ultimately to bog. Changes in Al geochemistry that may ensue as this transition occurs include decreases in pore and surface water Al concentrations with concurrent increases in peat bound Al.