Abstract
The ability of invertebrates to discriminate quantities is poorly studied, and it is unknown whether other phyla possess the same richness and sophistication of quantification mechanisms observed in vertebrates. The dune snail, Theba pisana, occupies a harsh habitat characterised by sparse vegetation and diurnal soil temperatures well above the thermal tolerance of this species. To survive, a snail must locate and climb one of the rare tall herbs each dawn and spend the daytime hours in an elevated refuge position. Based on their ecology, we predicted that dune snails would prefer larger to smaller groups of refuges. We simulated shelter choice under controlled laboratory conditions. Snails’ acuity in discriminating quantity of shelters was comparable to that of mammals and birds, reaching the 4 versus 5 item discrimination, suggesting that natural selection could drive the evolution of advanced cognitive abilities even in small-brained animals if these functions have a high survival value. In a subsequent series of experiments, we investigated whether snails used numerical information or based their decisions upon continuous quantities, such as cumulative surface, density or convex hull, which co-varies with number. Though our results tend to underplay the role of these continuous cues, behavioural data alone are insufficient to determine if dune snails were using numerical information, leaving open the question of whether gastropod molluscans possess elementary abilities for numerical processing.
Highlights
Continuous and discrete quantity information are important in guiding animal behaviour in virtually all aspects of life
Cognitive psychologists have shown that in these cases it is not necessary to assume the existence of a true numerical estimation system because an animal can use continuous cues, such as the amount of movement, the cumulative surface occupied by items, or the convex hull of the set as a proxy for n umber[23,24]
In Experiment 2c, we found no evidence that snails prefer denser to sparser clusters of bars, an indication that the convex hull is likely not a perceptual cue used by dune snail to choose their refuges
Summary
Many species, including humans, routinely estimate numerosity using non-numerical information that co-varies with number, such as the amount of movement, the cumulative surface area, or the convex hull of a set of o bjects[75]. In the species studied so far, cumulative surface area is the non-numerical cue most frequently used to discriminate different quantities of objects. When the area hypothesis was directly tested (Experiment 2b) we observed that the ability to discriminate two quantities disappeared This kind of results would indicate that an animal is primarily or exclusively using non-numerical cues to estimate quantity[7,23]. The adoption of rules of thumb can decrease decision time and reduce the need for neural computation, but in many cases it may lead to inaccurate assessment and to suboptimal decisions[93]
Sign-in/Register to view highlights & summary Talk to us
Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have
Schedule a callDisclaimer: All third-party content on this website/platform is and will remain the property of their respective owners and is provided on "as is" basis without any warranties, express or implied. Use of third-party content does not indicate any affiliation, sponsorship with or endorsement by them. Any references to third-party content is to identify the corresponding services and shall be considered fair use under The CopyrightLaw.
