Continental climate gradients in North America and Western Eurasia before and after the closure of the Central American Seaway

Abstract

The Gulf Stream, as part of the Atlantic Meridional Overturning Circulation (AMOC), is known as a major driver of latitudinal energy transport in the North Atlantic presently causing mild winters over northwestern Eurasia. The intensity of the AMOC throughout the Neogene, prior to the final closure of the Central American Seaway (CAS) in the early Pliocene, is still poorly known, but most authors assume that the circulation was considerably weaker than present. Here we address this issue from a continental point of view. We studied the past AMOC intensity by analyzing Neogene continental climate patterns along North American and Western Eurasian transects. Based on a total of 317 palaeofloras thermal latitudinal gradients are reconstructed for three Neogene time slices, namely the middle Miocene, late Miocene, and late Pliocene using the Coexistence Approach to obtain quantitative climate data. The obtained proxy-based, continental temperature gradients are evaluated against data from a selection of published General Circulation Model (GCM) simulations for the three time slices studied.Our study suggests that shallow thermal latitudinal gradients existed in North America and Western Eurasia throughout the Miocene but became strongly steepened in the late Pliocene. In both Miocene time slices studied, the higher latitudes were by up to 30 °C warmer than present (cold month mean), also at times with presumed pre-industrial CO2 such as the late Miocene. In the late Pliocene high-latitude, the temperature difference with respect to the present had decreased by up to 10 °C (cold month mean). Both mean annual temperatures and cold month means of the lower mid and low latitudes were at the present-day level throughout all three time slices, or even slightly below. In both Miocene time slices, zonal temperature means at both continental transects were similar in the mid and higher latitudes. However, several northwest European sites reveal very mild winter condition suggesting the early existence of a probably less intense Palaeo-Gulf Stream. The distinct thermal anomaly (annual and cold month means) today existing between North America and Western Eurasia appeared for the first time in the late Pliocene, attaining about 50% of the present-day magnitude. This supports the assumption that the AMOC intensified after the final closure of the CAS during the early Pliocene. The results obtained from the palaeobotanical proxies are in line with data from coeval marine archives, particularly with North Atlantic sea surface temperatures (SSTs) inferred from oxygen isotopes. However, the proxy-based thermal gradients are not well reproduced by a selection of GCM simulations, due to a well-known systematic underestimation of high latitude warming by GCMs for the Miocene and Pliocene time slices.