Abstract

In this paper, we take up three terms - containment, delay, mitigation - that have been used by the UK Government to describe their phased response to the COVID-19 pandemic. Although the terms refer to a political and public health strategy - contain the virus, flatten the peak of the epidemic, mitigate its effects - we offer a psychosocial reading that draws attention to the relation between time and care embedded in each term. We do so to call for the development of a form of care-ful attention under conditions that tend to prompt action rather than reflection, closing down time for thinking. Using Adriana Cavarero's notion of 'horrorism', in which violence is enacted at precisely the point that care is most needed, we discuss the ever-present possibility of failures withinacts of care. We argue that dwelling in the temporality of delay can be understood as an act of care if delaying allows us to pay care-ful attention to violence. We then circle back to a point in twentieth-century history - World War II - that was also concerned with an existential threat requiring a response from a whole population. Our purpose is not to invoke a fantasised narrative of 'Blitz spirit', but to suggest that the British psychoanalytic tradition born of that moment offers resources for understanding how to keep thinking while 'under fire' through containing unbearable anxiety and the capacity for violence in the intersubjective space and time between people. In conditions of lockdown and what will be a long and drawn-out 'after life' of COVID-19, this commitment to thinking in and with delay and containment might help to inhabit this time of waiting - waiting that is the management and mitigation of a future threat, but also a time of care in and for the present.

Highlights

  • In this paper, we take up three terms – containment, delay, mitigation – that have been used by the UK Government to describe their phased response to the COVID-19 pandemic

  • There will be a cascade of impacts on the economy and the National Health Service (NHS) that will affect the delivery of timely healthcare for years to come

  • Everywhere we look, the commentary on the COVID-19 pandemic focuses on the question of time and timing

Read more

Summary

10 Jun 2020

Any reports and responses or comments on the article can be found at the end of the article. We would suggest that mitigation, as a form of palliative care, needs to attend carefully to the total pain of COVID-19, and the conditions of radical uncertainty it produces, in ways that can respond to the multiple This would acknowledge the suffering of individuals in the present, but would not erase the cumulative effects of ongoing racism and social inequality, the brutalities of neoliberalism that have damaged working conditions in the NHS and its capacity to care, and the ongoing human-induced loss of habitats for non-human animals that have increased the likelihood of zoonotic disease transfer. For Bion an openness to what is unknown enables a relationship between, rather than a confusion of, internal and external reality, and the formation of an alliance for thinking made in contact others that could suspend action until it is thinking’s precipitate, rather than its substitute

Conclusions
Findings
Butler J
Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call