Consistent individual differences in behavior among beef cattle in handling contexts and social-feed preference testing

Abstract

Consistent individual differences (CIDs) in animal behavior, also known as personality or temperament, are measured in a variety of assays and are presumed to represent relatively stable traits of individual animals. Because these behaviors are presumed to represent stable traits, repetition of assays over short and long-term time frames and contexts is crucial; such repetitions are not commonly achieved in literature regarding the topic of CIDs, especially not in a singular study. In beef cattle, CIDs are often related to feeding and social preferences, which is relevant for extensively managed herds of ruminants. This study investigated the consistency of behavior among 50 breeding Angus x Hereford cows across repetitions within one year and over one year during three distinct contexts: handling and isolation in a chute corral system, choice in a social-feed tradeoff test, and response in a novel bucket approach test. We found that cows were consistent across short-term (assessed with repeatabilities [R]) and long-term (assessed with correlations across multivariate models [r]) timeframes in durations of behaviors exhibited in the management context (e.g. while handled [R = 0.60, r = 0.39], while traversing a cement chute [R = 0.69, r = 0.67] and an open squeeze stall [R = 0.76, r = 0.85]). Repeatable behaviors from the handling and isolation in chute system context were input into PCA with varimax rotation. Behaviors loaded onto three principal components that explained 66 % of the variance in the data and distinguished cows along axes of activity, fearfulness and excitability. Cows that were deemed less active (p = 0.010) and less excitable (p = 0.039) chose to approach the supplement bucket over gaining proximity to conspecifics in a social-feed tradeoff test. Even though the cows were not restrained in a squeeze stall, consistent individual differences in behavior across short (within year) and long-term (between years) timeframes were found. This suggests that future research can use unrestrained methods to evaluate cattle temperament, which could improve animal welfare and safety of handlers during experiments. Passive and less excitable beef cattle were more feed-centric, indicating that CIDs in behavior assays could potentially be used to predict feeding behavior because of an underlying stable trait in cows that ties response to handling and management with feed choice in a social-feed tradeoff task.