Consistency of Physical Therapist Discharge Recommendations in Acute Care

Abstract

Introduction: Physical therapists assist with discharge planning for hospitalized patients by making recommendations regarding a patient’s optimal discharge location and ongoing rehabilitation needs. The purpose of this study was to examine the consistency of discharge recommendations made by physical therapists with experience working in an acute care setting, when provided with a set of clinical vignettes describing hospitalized patients. Review of Literature: Considering the complex/multifactorial nature of making discharge recommendations, one would expect there to be inconsistencies among physical therapists. However, we are not aware of a previous study examining the level of consistency for discharge recommendations made by physical therapists, when reviewing a set of clinical vignettes. Subjects: Nineteen physical therapists working in an acute care setting. Methods: The physical therapists were provided with 10 clinical vignettes describing hospitalized patients via an electronic survey distributed across three rehabilitation departments. Each vignette described the patient’s medical condition, past medical history, prior level of function, living situation, key examination findings, and other general characteristics. After independently reviewing each case, the physical therapists selected a discharge recommendation from a list of standard options. Fleiss’ kappa was examined to assess the level of agreement among the physical therapists. Results: Overall, Fleiss’ kappa was 0.28, which reflects fair agreement among the physical therapists. Discussion and Conclusion: The 19 physical therapists who participated in this study only exhibited fair agreement with respect to their discharge recommendations. This relatively low level of agreement suggests that efforts to improve the consistency of discharge recommendations should be explored.