Conservative Management of Lisfranc Injury: A Systematic Review

Abstract

Category: Trauma; Midfoot/Forefoot Introduction/Purpose: Lisfranc injuries range from sprains to fracture-dislocations of the tarsometatarsal joints which include injury to the Lisfranc ligament complex. Most require surgical intervention. However, apparently stable injuries can be managed nonoperatively. The aims of the current study were to perform a systematic review of outcomes following nonoperative treatment of Lisfranc injuries. Methods: Following PRISMA guidelines and PROSPERO registered, a review was performed of the literature (2000 - 2021) reporting Lisfranc injuries considered to be stable and initially managed nonoperatively. Following exclusions, 8 papers were identified; 1 prospective and 7 retrospective studies. A total of 220 patients were studied with a mean age of 39.8 years and mean follow up of 4.3 years. Outcomes included function, displacement, rates of surgery and secondary osteoarthritis. Results: Four papers reported good outcomes, with adjusted functional scores ranging from of 82.6 to 100 (out of 100). However, poor outcomes were frequently reported. One paper reported that late displacement occurred in 54% of patients. Surgical intervention was required in 12.2 to 55.6% of patients. Rates of secondary osteoarthritis were 4.9 to 37.5%. Two papers directly compared operative to non-operative treatment. In an injury matched cohort, superior outcomes were reported in the surgical arm. Numerous limitations were identified, including a lack of consensus on what constitutes a stable injury. Furthermore, wide heterogeneity was identified due to use of different classification systems, PROMS, investigation modalities and treatment protocols. Conclusion: Reported outcomes following nonoperative treatment of Lisfranc injuries vary widely, including high rates of conversion to surgery. There is no agreed definition of what a stable Lisfranc injury is, and no agreed treatment protocol. With the advantage of modern imaging techniques, prospective research is needed to determine which Lisfranc injuries can be safely treated nonoperatively.