“Conflictive Subjectivity and the Politics of Truth and Justice in Cárcel de Amor”

Abstract

With few exceptions (see Marquez Villanueva 1966, 1976; Weissberger 1992; and Rohland de langbehn 1989), most approaches to Diego de San Pedro's Carcel de Amor have dwelled on the work's formal or generic aspects, its place in the emotive universe of courtly love and sentimental fiction, or questions regarding the identity and the possible religious affiliations of its author (see chiefly Whinnom 1974; and Rohland de langbehn 1989), often separating the work from the identifiable historical human context in which it was conceived. Yet Carcel de Amor's explicit portrayal of the enactment of justice at court, plus its mention of important historical events and contemporary historically-important place names from the closing years of the fifteenth century – the war against Granada, Sierra Morena, and the dominion of Penafiel – as well as its dedication to Diego Fernandez de Cordoba, alcaide de los donceles , husband of Dona Juana Pacheco, a kinswoman of the influential Tellez-Giron family of the lords of Penafiel, requires that close attention be paid to the work's social and political ramifications. The numerous references to contemporary personages and events in Carcel signal both its author's and the work's links to an immediate historical moment and its propinquity to one of the most powerful nobiliary clans of late fifteenth-century Castile, the Girones, bitter enemies of Fernando and Isabel.