Concerted Shifts in Absorption Maxima of Yellow and Red Plumage Carotenoids Support Specialized Tuning of Chromatic Signals to Different Visual Systems in Near-Passerine Birds

Abstract

Recent evidence that absorption maxima (λRmin) expressed by colorful plumage pigments align to diagnostic cone sensitivities of affiliated visual systems suggests that birds employ specialized signals in relation to their color vision. However, these studies compared different pigments and clades for the violet (porphyrins in non-passerines) and ultraviolet (carotenoids in passerines) sensitive system, which confounds chemistry and phylogeny with tuning patterns. To test whether signal alignments to violet (VS) and ultraviolet (UVS) systems transcend confounding factors, parallel analyses were conducted for a diversity of near-passerines, a group in which plumage carotenoids occur in taxa with either visual system. Conventional and phylogenetically informed analyses confirmed earlier findings: short wavelength absorbing (yellow carotenoid) pigments aligned λRmin with the violet-sensitive (V) cone of VS species but with the short wavelength-sensitive (S) cone of UVS species, whereas long wavelength-absorbing (red carotenoid) pigments aligned only with the S cone of VS species. More extensive variation among VS yellow carotenoids produced λRmin alignments to cone sensitivities that differed at shorter (peaks) versus longer (overlaps) wavelengths. Ancestral trait reconstructions indicated that signals evolved to match pre-existing VS systems, but did not resolve scenarios for UVS systems. Regardless of historical details, alignments expressed a higher-level pattern in which λRmin values were blue-shifted for yellow and red carotenoids in VS compared to UVS species, a pattern opposite that expressed by receptor sensitivities between systems. Thus, generalized functional designs attributed to avian color vision allow for specialized visual communication through the development of chromatic signals suited to each perceptual system.