Conceptualizations of Abandoned Mine Land Reclamation: A Case Study of the Daniel Boone National Forest

Abstract

The Daniel Boone National Forest (DBNF) contains numerous abandoned mine sites left over from eastern Kentucky’s history of coal mining, many of which are leaching contaminants into the environment. The United States Forest Service is acting to reclaim these sites to mitigate negative impacts. There are several other governmental and non-governmental actors in Appalachia with different conceptualizations of reclamation’s purpose. This research examines the mine land reclamation process on a protected area within a region with a history of resource extraction and builds on previous work to understand different conceptualizations of abandoned mine land reclamation in Appalachia. Content analysis was conducted on DBNF project documentation, interviews, and documentation from state and federal agencies, and NGOs. These documents indicate that government entities tend to conceptualize reclamation and its purpose in a siloed manner. This research also reveals that non-governmental actors tend to conceptualize reclamation in a holistic manner but are less able to exert control over an area. The DBNF largely conceptualizes the purpose of reclamation as achieving ecosystem restoration but may benefit from working more closely with NGOs and adopting a similarly holistic approach. Opening a dialogue between these actors could help address the knowledge gap present at the DBNF’s sites