Comprehensive immunohistochemical analysis of the gastrointestinal and Müllerian phenotypes of 139 ovarian mucinous cystadenomas

Abstract

Mucinous cystadenoma is one of the most common benign ovarian neoplasms. The immunophenotypes and histogenetic relationships of mucinous cystadenomas with a Müllerian-type epithelium have not been fully explored. We elucidated the direction of differentiation of the mucinous epithelium that constitutes mucinous cystadenomas. Special attention was paid to the existence of gastrointestinal (GI)-type mucinous epithelium, and its association with background Müllerian-type epithelium. Immunohistochemistry was performed in 139 cases of mucinous cystadenoma to evaluate the expression of Claudin-18 (CLDN18), a novel marker of gastric differentiation; CDX2, a marker of intestinal differentiation; and estrogen receptor (ER), a marker of Müllerian differentiation. We found that GI differentiation characterized by CLDN18 and/or CDX2 positivity was observed in mucinous epithelium of most mucinous cystadenomas (129/139 cases, 93%). In a subset of these cases, the tumor was composed of mucinous epithelium exhibiting an intermediate GI and Müllerian phenotype (CLDN18+/CDX2±/ER+). Of note, in 12 cases, a transition from background Müllerian-type epithelium to mucinous epithelium with GI differentiation was identified. A minor subset (6%) of mucinous cystadenomas was considered a pure Müllerian type because the epithelium exhibited a CLDN18-/CDX2-/ER+immunophenotype. In conclusion, mucinous cystadenomas consist of three major subtypes: GI, Müllerian, and intermediate types. Most mucinous cystadenomas are GI-type, and they should be considered a precursor of GI-type mucinous borderline tumors. The existence of intermediate-type mucinous cystadenomas, and areas of transition from Müllerian-type to GI-type epithelium suggest that GI-type mucinous epithelium can arise from Müllerian duct derivatives or surface epithelium exhibiting Müllerian metaplasia in the ovary.