Competitiveness of transgenic oilseed rape

Abstract

The competitiveness of two transgenic oilseed rape (Brassica napus ssp.napus) lines and their fertile transgenic hybrid was tested in field trials in Belgium and Denmark. The lines contained genes for male sterility, restoration of fertility and herbicide resistance. The competitiveness of the three transgenic lines was related to three non-transformed commercially-grown oilseed rape varieties: Drakkar, Topas and Line. As a reference of a more aggressive crucifer, white mustard (Sinapis alba) was also included in the experiment. The experimental design was a complete block design with two locations, monocultures and mixtures with barley (Hordeum vulgare), three plant densities, four harvest times and four blocks. The yield density relationship of the transgenic oilseed rape lines was not different from that of the non-transgenic varieties in either location. The first harvest times showed a vigorous biomass production of white mustard, which in turn produced a significant difference in the competitive ability between oilseed rape and white mustard. Later, this difference decreased, and in Belgium there was no difference at the last harvest time. Variations within populations may blur actual differences between lines and varieties, and it is argued that unless the experimental design covers a range of competitiveness for which it is possible to detect significant differences, test results reporting a lack of difference between transgenic and non-transgenic plants are of little value.