Comparisons of cancer detection rate and costs of one cancer detected among different age-cohorts in immunochemical occult blood screening.

Abstract

This study was carried out to compare the detection rate for colorectal cancer and the average costs to detect one patient with colorectal cancer among three different age-cohorts in immunochemical occult blood screening by OC-Hemodia. In a population-screening program, 17,432 subjects received an immunochemical fecal occult blood test. In a medical checkup for colorectal cancer 7,232 subjects received colonoscopy. They were divided into three groups according to their ages: younger (4,049 years); middle (50-59); and older (60+) groups. The detection rate for colorectal cancer and the average costs to detect one patient with colorectal cancer were evaluated among the three groups. In the screening program-based study, the cancer detection rate and the average costs for one colorectal cancer detected were calculated as 0.09% and $13,352, 0.28% and $4,555, 0.29% and $4,461 for the younger, middle, and older groups, respectively. In addition, in the medical checkup-based study, the detection rate and the average costs were calculated as 0.3% and $6,851, 1.5% and $1,517, 1.7% and $1,391 for the younger, middle, and older groups, respectively. In these two studies, the cancer detection rates were significantly different between the younger and middle groups (P < 0.05), and between the younger and older groups (P < 0.05). These findings indicate that the subjects aged under 50 have some disadvantage when carrying out the immunochemical fecal occult blood test--OC-Hemodia for colorectal cancer screening--from the viewpoint of screening efficiency as well as cost-effectiveness.