Comparisons and Interpretations of Charcoal and Organic Matter Radiocarbon Ages from Buried Soils in North-Central Colorado, USA

Abstract

The reliability of radiocarbon ages based on soil organic matter (SOM) from Holocene buried soils in Middle Park, Colorado, is assessed by comparison with ages of charcoal. On average,14C ages of SOM from buried surface horizons are 880 ± 23014C yr younger than charcoal ages from the same horizon. Humic acid (HA) and low-temperature (400 °) combustion residue (LT) fractions are 390 ± 230 and 1290 ± 23014C yr younger than charcoal ages, respectively, and HA ages are on average 860 ± 14014C yr older than LT fractions. We interpret the offsets between14C ages of charcoal and SOM fractions and the consistent offsets between the HA and LT fractions to reflect the duration of pedogenesis and different residence times of the SOM fractions examined here. The stratigraphic coherence of charcoal14C ages suggests short residence time on the landscape, with little subsequent reworking.14C ages of HA and LT fractions are complimentary to charcoal, and HA ages are interpreted to represent minimum ages for the onset of pedogenesis and LT ages are considered maximum ages for burial. The14C chronology from buried soils indicates an episode of hillslope erosion in Middle Park during the early Holocene, followed by a long period of land surface stability and soil formation between 9000–4500 BP. Two episodes of late Holocene hillslope erosion between 3500–2500 and 1000–500 BP correspond with warming recognized in the Colorado Front Range, while surface stability and soil formation between 2500–1000 BP is contemporaneous with evidence for cooling at higher elevations.