Comparison of Voltage-Source and Current-Source Shunt Active Power Filters

Abstract

In recent years, active power filters have been widely studied. The research has mainly concentrated on voltage-source active filters, but some attention has also been paid to an alternative-to current-source active filters. Since voltage-source pulsewidth modulation (PWM) technology is widely used in industrial applications, this has also been more common in active filter use. In addition, current-source technology has been said to have drawbacks compared to voltage-source systems, such as high on-state losses in the PWM bridge and inefficient inductive energy storage element on the dc side of the bridge. In the paper, the two active filter topologies are compared. First, the main circuits and space-vector modulation techniques used are studied and the digital control systems are presented. The filtering performances of the systems with different kinds of nonlinear load are examined and finally the power losses of the active filters are studied. The comparison is based on measurements with the prototypes built. The results clearly show the properties of the active filters examined. In addition, the results prove that current-source active filters also offer a considerable choice for harmonic filtering