Comparison of two preserved cartilage iliac crest cortical-cancellous bone blocks graft harvesting techniques in children: A prospective, double-blind, randomized clinical trial

Abstract

PurposeTo compare donor-site morbidity for alveolar bone grafting results following cartilage-preserving outer and inner cortico-cancellous iliac crest (OCIC and ICIC) bone block grafting in children. Materials and methodsPatients were randomly divided into two groups and prospectively reviewed. In the OCIC and ICIC groups, cortico-cancellous bone blocks were harvested at outer and inner iliac crest respectively. Patient characteristics and surgical parameters were compared; pain intensity and duration, lateral femoral cutaneous nerve (LFCN) injury, gait disturbance, scar and contour satisfaction were analysed postoperatively. ResultsForty-nine consecutive patients (OCIC, 24; ICIC, 25) were included. There were no significant differences in patient characteristics or donor-site surgical parameters. The mean pain score on the first post-operative day was significantly lower in the OCIC group (3.75±1.70) than in the ICIC group (5.20±2.08) (p=0.012). The pain duration was similar in the two groups (median: 5 days). Temporary LFCN injury only occurred in 3 patients in the ICIC group. Postoperatively, the duck and circle gaits were observed in the OCIC and ICIC groups, respectively. There were no significant differences in the claudication duration, scar and contour satisfaction between the groups. ConclusionOCIC bone graft harvesting is marginally advantageous in children due to less early postoperative donor-site pain and a lower risk of nerve damage.