Comparison of Two Diagnostic Criteria for Hepatopulmonary Syndrome-High Prevalence in Biliary Atresia.

Abstract

There is lack of clarity regarding the exact prevalence of hepatopulmonary syndrome (HPS) in pediatric liver diseases owing to lack of standardized diagnostic criteria. Thus, we aimed to do a comparative study of HPS with respect to its prevalence using the available diagnostic criteria. All consecutive children with biliary atresia (BA) and other chronic liver diseases (CLDs) were studied. Prevalence of HPS was compared using the 2 available criteria: demonstration of intrapulmonary vascular dilatation along with either alveolar-arterial oxygen difference (P [A-a] O2) on arterial blood gas analysis of more than 15 mmHg (criteria 1), or higher than age-appropriate calculated value for P (A-a) O2 (criteria 2). A total of 42 children in BA group and 62 in the non-BA CLD group were included. Using the criteria 1, the prevalence of HPS was 42.3%: 57.1% in the BA group and 32.2% in the CLD group, whereas using criteria 2, the prevalence was 48.1%: 61.9% in the BA group and 38.7% in the CLD group. Criteria 2 diagnosed 6 additional patients with HPS compared to criteria 1 (P value 0.405). BA subjects had higher risk (2.9-3 folds) of developing HPS compared to other CLDs. There is high prevalence of HPS in pediatric liver disease subjects. Age-appropriate formula for HPS diagnosis may be better applicable in pediatric population. BA subjects have a higher risk of developing HPS compared to other CLDs overall, irrespective of the severity of liver disease and/or portal hypertension.