Abstract

AimTo compare the secondary cancer risk (SCR) between different planning techniques for treatment of Ca. Left-Breast patient. Materials and methodsFive treatment plans; 3DCRT tangential fields with physical wedge (PW), enhanced dynamic wedges (EDW), electronic compensator (EC), IMRT tangential fields (ITF) and Volumetric modulated arc (VMAT) plan (partial arcs) with 6MV photon beams were generated for a carcinoma of Left breast patient of age 40 to a prescription dose of 50Gy in 25 fractions. The SCR was estimated using the organ equivalent dose (OED) concept with a linear-exponential, a plateau, and a linear dose-response model for OARs. Also, the low dose-bath volume (5Gy) was calculated for all the plans. ResultsFor contra lateral breast the SCR relative to PW were (linear, plateau, linear-exponential) (−26.0%, −35.0%, −39.0%) for VMAT, (−50.0%,−50.0%,−51.0%) for ITF, (−48.0%, −49.0%,−49.0%) for EC and (−33.0%, −24% , −25.0%) for EDW respectively. The relative SCR (plateau) for heart and left lung were (−66.0% & −73.0%) for VMAT, (−20.0% & −6.0%) for ITF, (−24.0% & −18.0%) for EC and ( −17.0% & −14.0%)for EDW. In contrast, for skin the relative SCR (linear - exponential) were 78.0%, −8.0%, −13.0% and −10.0% for VMAT, ITF, EC and EDW respectively. The 5Gy low dose volume relative to PW for VMAT was 201.45%, whereas the same for ITF, EC and EDW were 17.0%, −7.33% and −4.3%. ConclusionCompared to all plans, VMAT plan showed high conformity for CTV and superior heart and left lung sparing. But SCR for skin and the low dose bath volume were significantly high in VMAT. ITF plan showed relatively better sparing for contra lateral breast and heart. EC plan shows moderately good sparing for OARs while scoring least SCR value for skin next to EDW. EDW and PW plans were similar but later had high SCR for contra lateral-breast. Planning techniques like ITF and VMAT can be strongly considered for left breast, provided better skin sparing techniques and less dose spillage can be achieved.

Full Text
Published version (Free)

Talk to us

Join us for a 30 min session where you can share your feedback and ask us any queries you have

Schedule a call