Comparison of solar thermal and solar electric space heating and cooling systems for buildings in different climatic regions

Abstract

Solar thermal and Photovoltaic (PV) systems can save significant amount of non-renewable energy that are utilized to satisfy the energy services for buildings. The falling prices of PV in recent years increased the attractiveness of PV systems. The purpose of this research is to develop a systematic methodology for fair technical and economical comparison of reference and solar assisted systems. For this reason, the annual energy requirements for heating, cooling and DHW for a selected dormitory building under five representative climatic conditions were evaluated using the Hourly Analysis Program (HAP). At the same time, solar thermal and PV systems have been designed and simulated for the same building using Sketchup, Trnsys and PVsyst. Finally, a systematic comparison between the solar systems and five conventional systems have been carried out in terms of primary energy ratio, and Levelized Cost Of Energy (LCOE). For the case of Amman, solar thermal and electric systems achieved a non-renewable primary energy savings of 29% and 100%, respectively, whereas, they achieved LCOE savings of 15% and 62%, respectively compared to the best conventional system. The selection of the best solution for a given project requires a full understanding of the system performance and the interaction of its components rather than the technology efficiency only. This system performance depends on the building envelope, load patterns, availability of solar radiation, roof area availability, energy prices, and policies. Thus, a case-by-case analysis should be done for each project in each climatic region.