Comparison of soil water chemistry and sample size requirements for pan vs tension lysimeters

Abstract

A study was conducted to compare soil leachate chemistry and determine sample size requirements for tension vs pan (zero-tension) lysimeters. Analyses were performed on an annual and seasonal basis for one year of data collected at Pea Vine Hill, a forested site in southwestern Pennsylvania. On an annual basis, SO4−2, Ca+2, Mg+2, Mn+2, K+ and specific conductance were significantly higher in tension lysimeter samples but no chemical species were significantly higher in pan lysimeters. Seasonal comparisons indicated chemical differences between lysimeter types were variable with more significant deviations present during wet periods. Nearly all significant seasonal differences were comprised of higher concentrations in tension compared to pan lysimeters. Disparities in leachate chemistry between lysimeter types were ascribed to different sources of water collected by the instruments especially during wet periods. Sample size requirements were calculated for two biweekly periods for each lysimeter type at three confidence levels. Based upon calculated sample demands, pan lysimeter soil leachate chemistry could be characterized with fewer samples than tension lysimeters. Less than .30 samples were generally necessary for pan B-horizon lysimeters at the 70% confidence level. Sample requirements were usually unreasonable at higher confidence levels.