Comparison of SMOS and AMSR-E vegetation optical depth to four MODIS-based vegetation indices

Abstract

Abstract The main objectives of this study were to provide a proxy “validation” of the Soil Moisture and Ocean Salinity (SMOS) mission's vegetation optical depth product ( τ SMOS ) on a global scale, to give a first indication of the potential of τ SMOS to capture large-scale vegetation dynamics, and to contribute towards investigations into the possible use of optical vegetation indices (VI's) for the estimation of τ . The analyses were performed by comparing the spatial and temporal behaviour of τ SMOS relative to four MODIS-based VI's, with that of the vegetation optical depth from a similar sensor, AMSR-E ( τ AMSR-E ). 16-day and annual average values of the passive microwave optical depth ( τ ) for the year 2010 were obtained from SMOS (1.4 GHz) and AMSR-E (6.9 GHz) observations. The VI's chosen for this study were the Normalized Difference Vegetation Index (NDVI), Enhanced Vegetation Index (EVI), Leaf Area Index (LAI) and Normalized Difference Water Index (NDWI). The highest global-scale, annual correlation was found between τ SMOS and τ AMSR-E from ascending orbits (Spearman's R = 0.80). On global, annual scales, τ SMOS showed higher correlations with τ AMSR-E than with the VI's, while τ AMSR-E was more highly correlated with VI's than with τ SMOS . Timeseries of both τ and the VI's were made per landcover class, for the northern hemisphere, tropics and southern hemisphere. Although the large-scale spatial and spatio-temporal behaviour of τ SMOS and τ AMSR-E is generally similar, the results highlight some notable differences in observing vegetation with optical vs . passive microwave sensors, and certain crucial differences between the two passive microwave sensors themselves. Overall, the results found in this study give a good first confidence in the SMOS L3 τ product and its potential use in vegetation studies. These results provide an essential general reference for future (global-scale) vegetation monitoring with passive microwaves, for the future inclusion of τ SMOS in long-term, multi-sensor datasets, and for passive microwave algorithm development.