Comparison of self-perceived competence of recent dental graduates from the Universities of Otago and Dalhousie.

Abstract

This study investigates and compares the self-perceived competencies of recent dental graduates from the University of Otago (UoO) (Dunedin, New Zealand) and Dalhousie University (DU) (Nova Scotia, Canada). A validated survey was emailed to recent graduates from the UoO (December 2019) and DU (May 2020). Chi-squared statistical analysis examined the differences between groups. The response rate was 73% from the UoO class and 75% from the DU class. Out of 59 competencies, 11 items showed a significant difference. Orthodontics and the surgical aspects of dentistry were the main areas where significant differences have been observed between the two cohorts. Out of the four items in orthodontics, a significantly higher proportion of DU graduates felt more competent than graduates from UoO in three items ("performing orthodontic treatment planning," "performing space maintenance/regaining" and "performing orthodontic full-arch alignment"; p<.001). Similarly, graduates from DU felt significantly more competent in three of the eight items in the oral and maxillofacial surgery domain ("managing complications of oral surgery," "performing soft-tissue biopsies" and "managing trauma to the dentofacial complex"; p<.001), all requiring surgical training and skills. Of the differences identified, graduates from DU reported higher levels of self-perceived competence compared with their UoO counterparts, especially in the orthodontics and oral and maxillofacial surgery domains. This could be because DU students have more practice in these specialties during their training. The results suggest that increased exposure for UoO students in these areas may be beneficial to their self-perceived competence.