Comparison of Satiate and Restricted Feeding of Channel Catfish with Diets of Varying Protein Quality in Production Ponds

Abstract

AbstractA 2 × 3 factorial experiment was conducted using satiate and restricted feeding with 32% crude protein diets containing low, medium, and high quality protein. Protein quality in the experimental diets was varied primarily by substituting peanut meal and cottonseed meal for soybean meal. Percentages of lysine, the first‐limiting amino acid, were 1.14, 1.33, and 1.61 in the low, medium, and high quality protein diets respectively. Digestible energy concentration of the diets was 2.9 kcal/g. Channel catfish were grown from an average weight of 47 g to marketable size over a 15 wk period at a stocking density of 13,750 fish/ha in 400 m2 earthen ponds. Each treatment was replicated in three ponds. Fish in the satiation group were fed as much as they would consume each day for the 15 wk experimental period. Fish in the restricted group were fed as much as they would consume until the daily feed allowance reached 65 kg/ha, which was reached at approximately week 5 of the experiment, and thereafter, there was no further increase in feed allowance.There was no significant interaction between feeding regimen and dietary protein quality for weight gain or feed conversion. Weight gain and feed efficiency under both satiation and restricted feeding increased linearly as protein quality increased. Protein quality had no influence on protein efficiency ratio (PER) under satiate feeding but had a positive effect on PER under restricted feeding. Protein quality had a positive linear effect on dressing percentage under restricted feeding, but in those fish fed to satiation, dressing percentage only increased between the low and high quality protein treatments. Protein quality had a negative linear effect on muscle fat but had no effect on visceral fat under satiate or restricted feeding. These results indicate that channel catfish are sensitive to protein quality differences in practical feeds at both satiate and restricted feeding rates, and that reduction in protein quality reduces dressing yield and increases muscle fat in food size fish.